TreasurePlanet's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Sterile Atomic Fly]

wow

this was great.
it was very funny and i really got sucked into that world.
hope to see more of this series.
cheers/

BillyNapalm responds:

Thanks a bunch!

[zhjdgddf]

...

what i liked about this:
the intro was good and catchy, because of the music.
the collab in general is a good idea.

what i didn't like:
I didn't like that there seemed to be no point except for a bit of spam : )
and it was very offensive with very little humor.

overall. not great but it could have been worse.

Princess-Laucherella responds:

RACIST

[Cody Dodge: the Asteroid]

good and bad

what i liked:
it had a story
dialogue, sound effects were all present and in sync
the art was decent, but not great

what i didn't like:
the music was too loud in relation to the sound effects and speech
the scene with the pig talking took too long, and i got bored and left, later I cam back though, but i stil have not finished it because it is too slow for me.

Overall: I can tell you put a lot of work into it. and you have all the elemnts of a great flash, it's just the way it was paced ruined it for me.

King-N responds:

Thanks for the advice on pacing and sound.
I'll keep that in mind if I do another short.

[spongebob MADpants]

funny

what i liked:
the animation was good.
the coloring was good
there were no "jumpy" frames
that song always cheers me up

what i didn't like:
in some of the frames.... the super fast punching ones especially, the coloring is a bit off and the lines are sloppy.

overall it was good. and funny.

alonski22 responds:

thanks, ill try to make my next submission better than this one

[Katan]

epic

things i liked:
the music was both well composed and synced up perfectly with the movie.
the animation was very smooth
the design of the characters as well as the traps were very interesting.
the story. a complete story line with a begininng middle and end. AWESOME!!!

things I didn't like:
it was all good basicaly. there was a part that left a question in my mind (which may have been intentional) but there was another skeleton in the chambers, so did that mean that the evil one had done this before? or was it just an accident.

overall amazing film.

[max super introduction]

hmmm...

it's not really animation.
the art isn't bad though.
and i like that you alteast added a story to it.

sirsamy145 responds:

thanks :)

[Schmooper-Schmeroes]

overall

the colors, music, movements and character designs were all very pleasing.

you get a yes.

TheBoogley responds:

does that mean I can stay on in the national dancing competition? :3

[Mon-Turs N+R+G Sludge]

lol

the animation was cool
it was rough
but i enjoy the rough style more than anything
Loved it dude.
keep it up.

Galneda responds:

Thanks very much! Will-do!

[LARRY episode 1.5]

different.

i wish i had read the disclaimer first. So i could avoid being a bit disappointed.

But, even though this is not about Larry I really enjoyed the "fleshing out" of Larry's world. i enjoyed this alot.

Some of the jokes grossed me out.... actually just the horse one. Other than that it was great. I find it interesting that it seems innocent in regards to it's syle. But, it clearly is not.
Reminds me of South Park in that sense (this is not a bad thing.)

Thanks for sharing this story.

I look forward to returning to Larry's story line.

Cheers/

Jazza responds:

thanks man. sometimes i dont know where to draw the line or if jokes that i find humerous are just silly to others. they often are. oh well! can't win em all! as long as i enjoy it :P

[Liquid Life]

wow

this is great.
you put my animations to shame.
The flight was very sleek and smooth.
great job.
keep up the good work

ShikoxXxShadow responds:

thank you. ^^